Zoe Grossberg always wanted to be a famous pop star—but it was her sister, Cassie, who had the voice everyone noticed. While Zoe longed for the spotlight, though, Cassie never wanted to be seen, hiding behind her piano and under layers of clothing. Cassie’s voice couldn’t be hidden quite so easily, and eventually the sisters were discovered, signed to a label, and promoted as The Griffin Sisters. In the early 2000s, they were as famous as any teen pop star, but they only produced one album before breaking up. Twenty years later, the sisters don’t speak and have completely different lives. Zoe is a housewife in New Jersey while Cassie is secretly living in Alaska, where no one knows she can sing. But when Zoe’s daughter, Cherry, starts pursuing her own singing career, she tries to hunt Cassie down. She discovers more than just Cassie—she uncovers the entire history of the band, including the truth behind what happened to Russell D’Angelo, the bandmate who came between her mother and aunt. Weiner deftly explores the pop landscape of the early 2000s, when public body-shaming was even more prevalent than it is now. Zoe and Cassie are both realistic and flawed characters, each with their own challenges. Zoe knows that although she’s the prettier sister, she’ll never be talented like Cassie, and Cassie struggles with the size of her body and longs to hide from the audience, despite her miraculous voice. Theres’s a compelling and dramatic love triangle here, too, but the true love story is between two sisters and their music.